Buying Retro Games Safely

Buying authentic retro games can be challenging with so many reproductions on the market. Here’s how to shop safely and spot potential fakes before you buy.

Where to buy

Safer options

• Local retro game stores — Staff can often verify authenticity, and some use Operator devices themselves
• Game conventions and expos — Reputable sellers with return policies
• Established online retailers — Look for stores specializing in retro games
• Community marketplaces — Places like r/GameSale with seller reputation systems

Higher risk options

• Generic online marketplaces (eBay, Amazon third-party sellers)
• Social media marketplace groups
• Overseas sellers with very low prices

Red flags to watch for

Price too good to be true

If a rare game is selling for significantly below market value, it’s likely a reproduction. Research current prices before buying.

Stock photos only

Sellers using generic images instead of actual photos of the item are more likely to be selling reproductions.

No return policy

Legitimate sellers typically offer returns. Be wary of “all sales final” policies.

Vague descriptions

Watch for descriptions that say “reproduction,” “repro,” “new shell,” or avoid mentioning authenticity entirely.

Shipping from overseas

Many reproductions ship from overseas. While not always a red flag, combined with low prices it often indicates fakes.

Before you buy

1. Ask for photos of the front, back, and if possible, the PCB
2. Check the seller’s reviews and history
3. Research what authentic copies should look like
4. Compare prices across multiple sources
5. Use Playback’s authenticity check after purchase

After purchase

Once you have your game, use your Operator with Playback to verify authenticity. The app will indicate whether your cartridge is Official, Unofficial, or Unrecognized.

However, the authenticity check is not always a decisive indicator. You should also inspect:

• Label quality — Look for printing errors, wrong colors, or missing stamps
• Plastic quality — Check for unusual texture, color, or fit
• The PCB — The most definitive source. Open the cartridge and compare the circuit board with photos from the internet

See Spotting Fake Games for detailed visual inspection guidance.

If you receive a fake

• Contact the seller and request a return
• Leave honest feedback to warn other buyers
• File a dispute if the seller misrepresented the item